Posted by Dustin on 06.14.2009 at 11:04 am

As usual, first a recap, then some thoughts. Not much to recap this time, as a lot of the show was people crawling through tunnels 🙂

The show picked up with everyone knowing JD was dead and looking for his killer. Henry, as predicted, found him first and tried to save him . . . that’s why he was covered in blood. Shane joined up with the others at Wellington Manor, where Abby and Jeremy brought the Sheriff. Cal, who is apparently a nueroanatamist hooked the Sheriff up to an IV drip (which I guess they got from a hospital or something) and stabilized him. Abby meanwhile looked through the book her dad told her to get. She found out her mom was pregnant with Wakefield’s child at some point and felt it could be her. Shocking!

Soon everyone realized Beth had gone missing. They began looking around, Sully and Danny found a trail of blood leading them to some old prohibition tunnels under the manor . Several of them went into the tunnels, and Abby got cut off when a grate fell down on her.

Meanwhile Shea and Trish ended up stealing Shane’s truck to try and go find the psychic from the bachelorette party, thinking she might know where Madison was.

Back in the tunnels, Abby found a room where Madison was. They escaped and eventually climbed up a sewer drain, to be rescued by Trish and Shea who were on there way back to the manor.

Cal and his girlfriend meanwhile had made love, as she was turned on watching him save the sheriff. Later though the sheriff was gone! Everyone ran out to see Madison. Madison asked Abby if she liked the game, the man who took her said she would. Abby asked who took her? Madison said “the sheriff!” Meanwhile Shane was still inside with Mrs. Wellington, who was asleep in a chair. He went to wake her to tell her Madison was here. Then he saw blood pouring out, someone had stabbed her in the back with garden shears.

My Thoughts
Clearly they are making it look like the Sheriff is now the prime suspect, but he couldn’t have killed his old deputy last week. Did he take Madison though? Probably, only to keep everyone on the island so that he could lure the killer out.

Who is the killer? I still think Booth is a possibility because he was the only one not killed by the killer, and nobody knows where his body is.

I’m also wondering if there isn’t two killers at work here. At this point that might be the only way to explain it, as almost everyone can be accounted for when a murder happened.